I think I have an assignment for the folks at Merriam-Webster for the next edition of their dictionary. What is a word for a general manager that gave two-year contract extensions to players who both should’ve been dealt at last season’s trade deadline, but now finds himself needing to get rid of them to clear up a logjam on his roster? For now, let’s just call this particular GM by his given name, Jim Bowden.
The Washington Nationals’ general manager signed first baseman Dmitri Young and second baseman Ronnie Belliard last season as presumed one-year stopgaps for the injured Nick Johnson and Cristian Guzman. And both acquisitions were good ones. Young revitalized his career after nearly destroying it in Detroit, hitting .320/.378/.491 with 14 home runs and 74 RBIs. For that effort, he was the Nats’ lone All-Star representative and was named the National League Comeback Player of the Year. Belliard didn’t win any awards for his efforts, but hitting .290/.332/.427 with 11 home runs and 58 RBIs (along with only six errors at second base), nicely outperformed the minor-league deal Bowden signed him to in Spring Training.
Though I’m sure the Nats were grateful to Young and Belliard making meaningful contributions to what turned out to be a fourth-place (73-89) team in the NL East, Bowden initially admitted that he signed both players with the idea that they could be dealt for prospects in mid-season. This is from the same guy who traded for Alfonso Soriano in his walk year of 2006 and ended up keeping him for the entire season, only to watch him sign with the Chicago Cubs. But Washington received compensatory draft picks from the Cubs, so you can’t say Bowden didn’t get anything in return.
Since that worked so well for him the previous season, Bowden decided to take a similar approach with Young and Belliard, declining to move either player when he had the opportunity. But he wasn’t going to just repeat himself, either. No, just keeping these two players wasn’t going to be enough. The Washington Nationals were going to make a commitment. A financial investment, more specifically. Young was signed for $10 million, while Belliard agreed to a $3.5 million deal. Both contracts were two-year agreements - reached before the July 31 trade deadline.
Oh, you might say, Bowden was trying to protect himself in case neither Johnson nor Guzman recovered from their injuries. Okay, fair enough - especially since Johnson is a notoriously slow healer. And even if Johnson came back, Young could move to the outfield. Or not. They don’t call him “Da Meat Hook” because he has the lithe physique of a swimmer. First base was made for guys built like D.Y.
But Guzman was likely to return from his left thumb injury and was signed through this season, while Felipe Lopez had one more year of arbitration with the Nats. Neither player was going anywhere.
So that brings us to the Nationals’ current roster dilemma. Too many healthy players, not enough open roster spots. And Lopez has already made it quite clear that he has no intention of giving up a starting position.
“Bench?” López said Tuesday following a 9-1 thumping of the Detroit Tigers. “No. I already said that. No. Hell, no.”
Belliard, meanwhile, says he’s fine with whatever the team decides. But he might have been fanning himself with his two-year contract while saying that. Belliard is also being paid like a bench player, a role in which he happens to perform quite well, while Guzman and Lopez will draw paychecks exceeding $4 million. Given that Lopez could become a free agent after the season, he’d seem to be an ideal trade candidate. At least he might be if he were playing for any other general manager besides Bowden. No, he’ll probably hang onto Lopez. Maybe he’ll work out a contract extension, as well.
Did I mention that Bowden also signed Bret Boone - who had been retired for two years - shortly before Spring Training began?